Basic Admissions Information

During this summer of 2011 we took a tour of many of the Ivy League Colleges as well as several other private liberal arts colleges. We visited - in order - Cornell, Harvard, Brandeis, Brown, Yale, Vassar, Bard, and Oberlin. We also took a stroll through Wellesley, but didn't go to an information session or take a tour because it was a Sunday evening.

We wanted our 14 year old daughter, Mollie, to have a sense of these schools as she enters high school and we thought that looking at colleges now might help make the process much more relaxed when the time comes to make important decisions. We also visited family and friends in the Boston area and that made for a really nice trip. Last spring we also visited Princeton and Columbia when we visited family in the New York City area, and we took a weekend trip to visit Oberlin and Kenyon here in Ohio as well.

After visiting all these colleges we are beginning to get a sense of certain patterns and certain concepts that almost all of the admissions officers say. Those generalizations are what I want to include in this section of the blog.

What do selective colleges look for in an applicant?

HIGH SCHOOL GRADES
The admissions officers in all the colleges we looked at said that the most important piece of information is the high school academic record. They want to see not only a strong GPA (Grade Point Average), but they also want to see that a student has taken advantage of what their high school has to offer and has taken Honors and AP classes that are available to them.

All the schools said that they look at "context" - in other words, the type of high school a student goes to. If a high school only offers 3 AP classes, a student who attends this school will not be compared unfavorably to a student who attends a high school that offers 30 AP classes. Admissions officers operate in different regions of the country and it is their job to become familiar with the different types of high schools and what they have to offer.

Every admissions presentation also made it clear that they want to see an upward trend in the student's transcript. They expect that a student's grades and the rigor of a student's classes will increase rather than decrease. If they see a downward trend in grades as the student goes through high school they get concerned.

SAT AND ACT SCORES
In the highly selective schools everything counts and I've included the middle 50% of scores in the blog postings for all of the schools we have visited. However, most of the admissions officers downplayed these tests in their presentations, although they did tell us the average scores.

The good news is that most of the schools said they will take the highest scores in each area to give students the benefit of the doubt, so it is a good idea to take these tests several times.
Students in 7th and 8th grade can take the SAT and the ACT through several talent search programs around the country. Mollie took them through the Northwestern University Midwest Academic Talent Search (NUMATS) and it was a very good experience for her. Several of my students have done the same thing and the feedback I have gotten is that it was a real confidence booster to do this.

Schools are definitely not just looking for perfect scores and made it clear that, although the scores are a factor in acceptance, they try to look at the whole person.

EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITIES
The trend seems to be that selective colleges are looking for students who have developed an interest in several activities or clubs and have stuck with those things throughout high school. This is more interesting to a college than a student who is involved in many, many activities, but has not really developed leadership or skill in any one area. The admissions officer at Brown said something like, "If you tell us that you are involved in 20 clubs or activities, not only does it look like you are padding your resume - you ARE padding your resume."

We heard a number of people talk about being interested in what students are passionate about and how they spend their time outside of the school day - even beyond school extracurricular activities. One example was given of a student who babysat for her neighbors to help them out and was downplaying the way in which she had spent her time. The admissions officer was actually very interested in what she had done and it turned out that she had really been of service to these neighbors. The point was that all activities are important in that they indicate a student's character and quality.

ESSAYS
Some of the admissions officers said that the essay is important in getting to know the student, some said that grades are the most important thing they look at, and some said the essay is the most important part of the application because it gives the college the clearest understanding of the student as an individual.

Whatever the case, all of them said that students should write about what they know in words they know, and that they want to hear the student's voice. The essay is a window into the student's life and they want to be able to see through that window clearly. They said that they like to read essays that bring them into the student's world, that make them feel that they can see what the student is feeling and perceiving.

The admissions officer at Vassar said that it is OK if a student hasn't changed the world yet because most 17 year olds haven't. She said the best things to write about are the simple things and she gave an example of a student who wrote about the things that are in her bedroom and how those things were a reflection of her as a person. She also said it is important to indicate the ability for self-reflection. Some students write beautiful essays about a person who has impacted them, but the essays are all about the other person and not about the applicant. The admissions officer said something like, "It would be nice if we could admit the person to Vassar who was written about in the essay, but that is not the person who is submitting the application!"

Everyone also said that it is important to edit and proofread!! The admissions officer at Brown said to be very careful, if you are going to apply to Brown, that your essay does not say, "I really want to go to Yale." A point well made!

OTHER FACTORS
There is so much to learn about this and I realized that I need to find some books that are written by people who have worked in Admissions because not everything can be said in these information sessions. Right now I'm reading a book called, "Admission Matters: What Students and Parents Need to Know About Getting Into College" by Sally Springer and Marion Franck. It has a lot of very frank and helpful information in it. I just went to our local library and checked this one out - but I'm sure there are a plethora of books about this topic on the market. It is a very hot topic right now!!

One last thing I want to say is that I developed a strong opinion on this college tour that it is really important for students to be true to themselves and to pursue things they are genuinely interested in and passionate about. They shouldn't try to calculate only what elite colleges are looking for because what these schools seem to be looking for are genuine people who will make the most of their experiences at their colleges. I think that admissions officers are pretty well trained to sniff out students who simply add experiences to their lives because their parents have paid for them to attend expensive camps or take expensive trips. The woman who gave the presentation at Yale said that they want students who will give back to the community. They are not only looking for students who have strong opinions, but they want students who will also listen to the opinions of others. So, it seems like it is important for students to develop from the inside out - to cultivate curiosity, integrity, commitment, compassion and determination. If they do these things, keep their grades up, prepare for the standardized tests, carefully complete applications and turn them in on time they will find success in whatever they do.

P.S. Almost every tour guide made some reference to Harry Potter! Residence Halls, dining areas, Yale's lawn for Quidditch...


Monday, August 15, 2011

Oberlin




We visited Oberlin last spring and went to the Information session and took the tour at that time. We fell in love with it then and Mollie was very excited about it as a possibility for her college education. We wondered how we would feel about it after visiting the Ivy League schools on the East Coast, but when we arrived in Oberlin we fell in love with it all over again! We all felt comfortable and at home and we were so glad to be back!

Oberlin was the first college in the country to allow people of all minorities to attend, and it was also the first college to allow women to attend. Its Environmental Studies building is the most sustainable college building in the world and its Conservatory of Music is world renowned. It is only an undergraduate school which means that undergraduates are the primary focus. The college has a feeling of excellence combined with a sense of clarity and calmness. All of the students we have met have been highly intellectual and yet down to earth. I get the feeling that students are very well taken care of at Oberlin and that while they are being stimulated intellectually they are also being nurtured as whole people.

Oberlin also has a competitive Creative Writing program and one of the best Environmental Studies programs in the country. Both of these are great options for Mollie and, at this point, they still seem to be some of the best possibilities for her. In other words, after visiting so many other schools, Oberlin still seems like the best fit. There is still a lot of time left before she has to make any decisions, but it was interesting to go back there and have the same feeling as we had originally. For Mollie the positive associations with Oberlin were very strong and she felt very happy there.


The other things that we noticed and liked about Oberlin: a bike co-op through which students have easy access to bicycles, a "green" dorm for Freshman students, energy use monitored in buildings throughout the campus, reduction in use of cars, composting and recycling, and vegetarian and vegan food options. Because the Environmental Studies program is so strong the focus on sustainability issues permeate campus life. We didn't see a focus this strong on any of the other campuses we visited which leads us to believe that Oberlin, as an entire campus, is probably on the cutting edge of environmental sustainability issues.

The photos I've included on the blog are as follows: the pond is in front of the Music Conservatory, the trees are part of an orchard connected to the Environmental Studies building, The Oberlin Market is the health food store and bakery downtown, and the other building shows typical 1800's architecture at the college. There was a sidewalk sale the day we were there, so we got a taste of Oberlin in the summer - laid back, progressive, interesting, dynamic. Could be a very nice place to spend four years of college...
Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT scores:
Reading 650-740
Math 630-710
Writing 650-740
ACT 28-32

Percent of applicants accepted: 22%
Percent of returning sophomores: 94%


Sunday, August 14, 2011

Bard



We went to Bard spontaneously because we had an extra day and we discovered that it was only 35 miles north of Vassar. It was a wonderful jewel in our trip and quickly became one of our favorites.

First, the location...Below is a description of the campus from the Bard website:

"As a residential college, Bard provides an exquisite campus setting in which students pursue their academic interests and craft a rich social life. The fusion of two historic estates, Bard's park-like campus covers more than 500 acres of fields and forested land bordering the Hudson River. The Catskill Mountains, to the west, can be viewed from many student residences and from the grounds and gardens of Blithewood (the mansion that houses The Levy Economics Institute of Bard College). Walking trails crisscross the campus through wooded areas, along the Saw Kill stream, and down to the river."

When you drive into Bard you simply come upon it in the woods, which is a very different experience than trying to find a college in the middle of a large urban city. I really felt that the setting would be conducive to studying, thinking, learning, and growing.

When we arrived in the Admissions Office, the Director of Admissions began talking to us a very friendly, casual way. She spent quite a lot of time with us, was welcoming and open, and even walked us across campus to the Center for Environmental Policy. We didn't know that she was the Director of Admissions until we got her card at the end of our visit! While we were talking to someone at the Center for Environmental Policy, an English professor came in for a meeting and in a down-to-earth and engaging way said to Mollie, "We hope you come to Bard." We felt comfortable and happy to be on the campus and that feeling is more and more what I am looking for in colleges that we consider for Mollie. I am much more interested in a college having a sense of nurturing Mollie as a person than I am a college that is prestigious or is a brand name. It is possible, I suppose, for a college to be nurturing, prestigious and a brand name. But, as parents, we are most interested in the nurturing aspect of a college - balanced of course with challenging and dynamic coursework. Bard seemed to have both qualities well in hand.

So, several things that we really liked about Bard aside from the setting and the Admissions Director! All incoming freshman start their year at the end of the summer with the 3 week "Language and Thinking Program" in which they read a variety of genres, work on writing projects, and engage in small group discussions. Then, after the winter holiday, the Freshman meet together again for another 3 week course called "Citizen Science" in which they learn the basics of the scientific method through the study of a particular topic. This gets them grounded in science at the beginning of their course of study at Bard to encourage students to become engaged in the sciences. First year students also take the "First Year Seminar" as part of the first year set of courses. This gives them a strong background in a basic liberal arts education and includes works by Plato, Virgil, Augustine, Dante, Shakespeare, Galileo, Marx, Darwin, and Nietzsche.

I liked the idea that the Freshman students come together to study these topics. I think this would ground them in certain knowledge and would also help them to bond with each other as they move through a common academic process.

The other thing that was very exciting about Bard is the Bard Center for Environmental Policy. It is actually a graduate program, but has a 3/2 program for undergraduates in which a student could do 3 years at Bard College as an undergraduate student and then complete their Master's Degree in another 2 years. A student can get a Master of Science in Environmental Policy and a Master of Science in Climate Science and Policy. The purpose of the program is to develop environmental leaders who can enter the workforce with the skills needed to impact environmental policy. Eban S. Goodstein, the Director of the Center said the following, "We are alive at an extraordinary moment, one that demands an extraordinary responsibility, especially from graduate schools focused on environmental policy."

We were very pleased with our excursion to Bard - it was well worth the trip. We visited Theodore Roosevelt's home on the way from Vassar to Bard, and could also have visited the Vanderbuilt Mansion had we chosen to take another detour. It's such a beautiful area - I'm sure that's why these prominent families chose to live there!

Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT scores:
Reading 680-740
Math 650-680
Writing - no information listed
ACT - no information listed

Percent of applicants accepted: 35%
Percent of returning sophomores: 90%

Friday, August 12, 2011

Vassar



Vassar is located in the Hudson Valley an hour and 45 minute train ride from New York City. It has 24oo students, 25% of whom are from New York, 80% of whom double major, and 40% of whom study away at some point during the college career. Vassar was an all girls college, but is now co-ed with approximately 45% men (I can't remember the exact number, but it was more than I expected it to be). The average class size is about 17 with advanced classes being about 10 students. There are not distribution or general education requirements - which seems to be a general trend in these kinds of schools.

One of the things we found interesting about Vassar is that there is a 500 acre working farm (appropriately called the Vassar Farm) that is part of the school. It has hiking trails and also seems to have a community garden from what we could tell. It seems like community members have garden plots on the farm because we saw a whole variety of different plots that didn't seem like they could be part of one organized garden. We hiked around it the evening after we went on the tour and we automatically associated it with the 1000 acre Glen Helen that is attached to Antioch College. I was disappointed to find out that the farm is not used to grow food for the students at the college because that seems like a perfect use for it in this day and age. The Admissions officer said that years ago, when the college was smaller, the farm did provide food for the students, but that now that the college is bigger they get their food elsewhere. That didn't make a lot of sense to me because one could grow a whole lot of food on 500 acres!

One of the things that the Admissions officer said to the students was that the essay on the college application should give the reader a window into who you are. She said it is OK if you haven't changed the world yet - most 17 year olds haven't. The best essays are about simple things and one student wrote about the things in her room and how those things were a reflection of who she was. The Admissions officer also said to make sure you write about yourself and show your ability to engage in self-reflection. For example, many students write beautiful essays about a person who has impacted them, but they forget to write about themselves in the essay. I have seen this, also, when I have my students write essays.

We were not particularly impressed by Vassar and that surprised me because when we looked at it on their website it was one of the colleges that we most wanted to visit. I don't know what it was about it - we just didn't click with it at all. I really liked the student who gave the tour - I thought she was very balanced and centered, so I'm sure that the school attracts very interesting students. It just left me cold for some reason that I can't really explain. That shows the necessity of visiting colleges because some of them you click with and can imagine being there (or imagine your child being there) and others you just don't vibe to at all. I also didn't like Poughkeepsie, the town were Vassar is located - I thought it would be a much nicer town and I didn't think it was anything special. There are some nice shops and restaurants near the college, but when we walked through that area in the evening it was pretty dead. I thought that Vassar would be a place we would look at seriously, but I doubt that we will at this point. However, things can always change...

Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT scores:
Reading 670-740
Math 640-720
Writing 660-750
ACT 29-32

Percent of applicants accepted: 24%
Percent of returning sophomores: 96%

Wellesley

We didn't take a formal tour or attend an information session at Wellesley because Mollie isn't interested in attending an all-girls college. I haven't really looked into Wellesley for this reason, but it is such a pretty place! We were visiting friends who live nearby, so we walked around on a Sunday evening. It was pretty empty and I don't think there are any students on campus in the summer - or at least it didn't seem like it - but we could still get a feel for the campus. It was like a beautiful park and seemed like a great place to study and develop the intellectual life! We enjoyed our walk and we also liked the nearby town.

Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT:
Reading 640-740
Math 630-74o
Writing 650-750
ACT 28-31

Percent of applicants admitted: 34%
Percent of returning sophomores: 96%

Yale




I have to say that we were completely pleasantly surprised when we visited Yale. I almost skipped over it because I thought that, being in the middle of New Haven, Connecticut, it would not be a very nice place. Wow, was I wrong! Yale has one of the most beautiful campuses we saw! And it is so obvious that the school has resources as you walk around and look at the buildings. Many of them are old, Gothic, and have stunningly beautiful architecture. They are also well taken care of so the atmosphere on campus is nice, nice, nice.

Downtown New Haven is sort of part of the campus, so you are right in the middle of the city when you are at the college. Mollie and I noticed, when we walked around after the tour, that only a block or so away from campus in one of the parks things started to get a bit seedy like many big city downtown areas. We all had to use the bathroom and the Starbucks that was a block from campus wouldn't let us use theirs unless we bought something, but the Starbucks across from campus let us walk right in. The feeling just a block away was noticeably different. I think it would be important simply for students to be aware of this, but it doesn't need to deter anyone from going to Yale! And it could be helpful for doing community service and also also for staying more in touch with reality.

Yale College has 5000 undergraduates and Yale University has 6000 graduate students. The distribution requirements offer students a lot of choice along with some structure and 50% of students change their major while at Yale. I actually think this is a good sign because students are allowed to explore their interests. The students can take 2 years to decide on their major - like many of the other schools we visited. There are 36 required classes and 12 of those can be in whatever the student chooses. The others are requirements for a major and core writing intensive classes. Yale also has a "shopping period" for the first several weeks of class so that students can look at a number of classes they may want to choose from, sit in on class, get a copy of the syllabus, hear a few lectures. This is the same kind of thing that Brown does and, in fact, when we visited Yale we began to have difficulty distinguishing between Yale and Brown because they have many similarities.

We really liked the woman who did the information session. She is a Yale graduate and looked like she was in her mid-thirties. She was articulate, but very down to earth and seemed accessible in a way that surprised me. She said that the atmosphere at Yale is collaborative and it is not a competitive academic environment, and she also said that it feels like a small liberal arts college even though it is fairly large for
a liberal arts school. About 80% of graduating seniors have some kind of international experience and most go abroad during the summer. There is a Yale program in Bejing, which sounded good in terms of Mollie being able to continue to learn about the Chinese culture. Yale is better known for its humanities department, but the sciences are developing there as well.

One of the most interesting thing about campus life for students at Yale is the Residential College system. Students are placed in a living environment called a Residential College where they stay for all 4 years. There are 12 colleges and each one has a separate area on campus where students live and eat. There is a dean for each college who helps students with academics and there is also a faculty member who is a "master" - someone who is in charge of the social activities for the college. So, for example a master might take students to see a Broadway play or go on an excursion to a museum. The master also arranges for famous people to come to Yale and have tea and a discussion with students in the college.

The campus definitely has some Harry Potter-ish places. One is a large lawn on which the Quidditch team plays (yes, I guess Quidditch has become an official game!), and the other is the main dining hall that looks suspiciously like the Great Hall at Hogwarts! I know that the Harry Potter movies were filmed at Oxford, but the Yale dining hall really makes you feel like you are at Hogwarts! I also kept looking at the old paintings on all the campuses we visited and thinking that they were going to start talking and
moving! There is also a rare books library that is amazing - I mean truly amazing! We saw original notebooks written by Henry Miller, notes by Langston Hughes, and many, many more primary sources. We could have all spent hours in there just looking at the displays. Students can use the rare books, but they have to be taken off the shelf by a librarian because the books are kept in a place where there is less oxygen so the books don't deteriorate. The books can't be checked out of the library, but what a treat it would be to get your hands on some of those books!!!

I liked what the Admissions officer said about what they are looking at in students who are accepted to Yale. They have only a 7% acceptance rate and I asked her how they decide among so many really good applicants. She said that there are many students they would like to accept but they just don't have enough space and she said that it is a very human process. She did say that they are not just looking at the top GPA or the top SAT scores, but that they are interested in who the student is as a person and a community member. One thing I thought was very interesting was that she said that they are looking for students who not only have strong opinions, but also for students who can listen to other's opinions. I hadn't heard that before and I think it was well said. The context of where a student has gone to high school is considered (all the colleges said this), so if a student has attended a high school where only 2 AP classes are taught they don't expect them to have as many AP classes as a student who attended a school with 30 AP classes. But she also said that they like to see how a student has ENGAGED with their high school and with what was available to them. I thought that was an interesting way to phrase this statement. Yale is looking for students who will make the most of their opportunity at Yale and they want to know what the student will give back to the community.

All in all, our visit to Yale was surprising, pleasant, encouraging, interesting, engaging - we loved it!! I can also see us revisiting Yale as a possible place for Mollie to apply. It is in her top 3 favorites right now.

Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT scores:
Reading 7oo-800
Math 710-790
Writing 710-800
ACT 32-35

Percent of applicants accepted: 8%
Percent of returning sophomores: 99%


Thursday, August 11, 2011

Brown



Brown has an open curriculum in which students choose their own classes, so the selling point is that students who are in a class WANT to be there. Brown has a "shopping period" the first two weeks of class during which students can attend a variety of classes to decide whether they want to take them. The Admissions officer said that students are the "architect of their own curriculum." There are several thousand classes to choose from an
d many of them do not have prerequisites.

Students have to take a minimum of 30 classes - approximately 4-5 classes a semester, and they pick their "concentration" (not called their "major" at Brown - we were told) by the end of their sophomore year. The school has two grading options: 1/ the traditional A-F option that students choose for classes in their area of concentration, and 2/ the Pass/Fail option that students can choose so that they can take classes out of their comfort zone.

The advising system at Brown is very comprehensive because of the open curriculum. The university seems to want students to have a lot of people to go to for advice, so they have a faculty adviser, a peer adviser, a concentration adviser - and a study abroad adviser and a thesis adviser if the student studies abroad or does a thesis. That sounds impressive and probably works for many students, but having had various advisers throughout my life I wonder how that works in reality. I like the idea of the open curriculum, but I think that students need to be very self-directed to go to a school like this because I think it would be easy to get lost and not really find a direction. However, if students know what they want to do and are inner directed it seems like there would be a lot of great opportunities to develop as a person.

The Rhode Island School of Design (probably the best art school in the country) is located right next to Brown, and students at Brown are able to take up to 4 classes at RISD. As an artist, that really appealed to me! Saul's nephew, Jesse, went to RISD and it sounds like there is a reciprocal relationship in which students there also had the option to take classes at Brown, but Jesse said
he didn't have time to do that because of the rigor of his classes and all the time it took to complete his work. I'm guessing that probably happens with the Brown students as well, but what an opportunity! Being able to go to the RISD Museum of Art and take part in art events would be a real plus as well.

Providence, Rhode Island, where Brown is located, is about an hour south of Boston and it is a beautiful city. The downtown area has been well taken care of and it feels safe and clean. We walked around Providence after visiting Brown and really liked it.

I think that Brown would be a great option for Mollie and it is a school I could see us going back to and looking into further. Right now Mollie is not as interested in it, but we visited so many places it will take time for things to sink in. The whole place - the university, RISD, and Providence - felt like a great place to be. It is cultured and has a lot going on, but it does not have the hassled feeling of a large city.



Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT
Reading 660-760
Math 670-770
Writing 670-770
ACT 29-33


Percent of applicants admitted: 9%
Percent of returning sophomores: 98%

Brandeis


Brandeis is located about 9 miles from Boston in Waltham, MA. It has a completely dif
ferent feel from the colleges that are closer to the city because it is in a suburb. We arrived at Brandeis after practically being chased off the Harvard campus by a meter maid and someone who wanted out parking spot. I ran into the Admissions building to find out where to park and one of the Admissions officers walked me out to the parking lot, showed me where to park, and told me not to worry at all if we were given a ticket - that we could just bring it into the office and they would take care of it. Wow! What a different reception - it was so different it was startling!

Albert Einstein, Eleanor Roosevelt, Abraham Maslow, and Leonard Bernstein helped found the physics, psychology, and music departments at Brandeis and the college has a casual air of excellence. The information session was one of the best we heard because the Admissions officer was very organized, had a power point presentation with a lot of information and visual aids, and she made her points clearly and concisely. The campus has the feeling of being new because the buildings are modern, so it is completely different from many of the liberal arts colleges on the East Coast that have old gothic buildings on their campuses. I didn't really like the feel of the campus because of the new modern buildings - it didn't have much character and didn't seem like a place I would want to study for 4 years. But I tried to look past that because it is a very good school and people, not buildings, give something its quality. Our tour guide was sort of quirky and we talked about the need to judge a school on its merits and not on the quality of the information sessions or the personalities of the tour guides.

The school has a long term commitment to social justice and equality, undergraduates are able to do a lot of research, there is no core curriculum, and about 50% of Juniors travel abroad. There is also funding for unpaid internships that students can apply for. Students are able to double or even triple major in different subjects which I found very interesting having visited Cornell where it seemed like it would be difficult to seek out new interests and add a major.

There seems to be a commitment to environmental sustainability on the campus - something that Mollie is interested in seeing when she looks at schools. They had a living roof, several buildings that had been designed to be environmentally friendly, and a "green, no-mow" lawn that did not use pesticides and does not require mowing.

While the buildings are new and modern there is one building that stands out and is really amazing. It is the sophomore dorm and is an exact replica of a castle - I think from Scotland! Apparently the writers from the TV show "Friends" went to Brandeis and they wrote many of their scripts based on interactions they had in the coffee house "Chums" that was located in the castle during their time at Brandeis. (I think it's still there.) We found that amusing because we just recently finished watching all the episodes of 10 years of "Friends" and we love the show!

We really enjoyed our time at Brandeis and were very impressed by it, but it doesn't seem like a place that Mollie will want to revisit or attend. That could change in 4 years, but that's the way we feel about it now. It's a great school, though, and I think a student could have a very good experience there.

Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT:
Reading 630-730
Math 640-730
Writing 640-720
ACT 28-32

Percent of applicants admitted: 35%
Percent of returning sophomores: 92%

Harvard




Harvard held some surprising experiences and impressions for us. It is located in Cambridge, just outside downtown Boston, and the area is a lot more gritty and seedy than I expected it to be. Our GPS went haywire telling us to turn right, no turn left, no make a u-turn, now Harvard is 1/2 mile away, now it is 3 miles away - you get the picture. We drove around Harvard Square 3 times and didn't even figure out that it was Harvard Square until we left the campus and were on our way out of Cambridge! We left in plenty of time to arrive at the tour with room to spare, but ended up scrambling for a parking spot, running through campus to the admissions office (which was not in an obvious place AT ALL) and getting there just as the tours were leaving. However, we all had to use the restroom by that time, so we ran to the bathroom and then dashed out of the building to barely catch the last tour several blocks away. By the time we went through all that we were exhausted - and then...it started to rain. Saul thought this should go in some kind of Chevy Chase family vacation movie about visiting colleges - it was a comedy of errors for sure.

I couldn't believe how many tours there were at the same time as ours. People were milling around everywhere and we began to suspect that this was more of a tourist attraction than a college planning tour as there were many people who did not even have kids with them! There were hundreds of people! That only led to things being more frenetic and I did not have a settled or happy feeling on the campus. It seemed older, more run down, and dirtier than I expected it to be and it didn't seem welcoming or personal. Now, reflecting back on the campuses we visited, Harvard's campus was actually one of the least appealing.

However, our tour guide was really great. She seemed balanced, very smart, but not some kind of genius type that you couldn't relate to. I asked her how she handled the pressure and what it was like to go to school there. She said that the most difficult thing she had to deal with was getting over comparing herself to other people. She said that when she first came to Harvard one of her neighbors in the dorm had started a nanotechnology company and was a millionaire at age 18. She wondered, "What am I doing here?" Then she realized that she was lucky to be there and stopped worrying about other people's accomplishments. It was interesting, in that situation, to get a student's perspective about this iconic place.


Mollie is standing in front of the statue of John Harvard, the most photographed statue in the U.S. except for the Statue of Liberty - according to our tour guide. It took quite a few tries to get Mollie in front of the statue because so many people were taking photographs of each other - and notice that I cut off his head!! Well, not to worry because apparently the statue and its inscription contain 3 lies: 1/ It is not really a statue of John Harvard because the photos of him were burned in a building fire and no one knows what he really looks like; 2/ John Harvard did not really found Harvard; and 3/ Harvard was not founded on the date inscribed on the statue. I think it's sort of symbolic that this famous statue in the middle of campus contains these deceptions because my impression is that the greatness of Harvard is a bit of a myth and a deception in itself! Don't get me wrong - I'm sure Harvard is a great place for some people, but I think that the myth that Harvard is THE place to go is something people believe in without thinking about it very deeply - like the lies on the statue.

I have read and heard that Harvard is not necessarily the best place for undergraduate students - that it is a survival of the fittest kind of place. It is a research institution and undergraduates are not the priority. I've also read that there is not really any research that indicates that one gets a better education at Harvard than at many other very good colleges. The school has a lot of money and resources, and there is prestige that goes along with getting into Harvard, but I think there are other more important things to look for in a college experience.

Our parking meter had only 2 hours on it, so that limited our time at Harvard. As we got to the car we were starving and luckily had food with us because finding another parking spot would be close to impossible. As we were sitting in our car hungrily chomping down on our food, the meter maid (do we still call them that?) came by to check the meter (which had about 2 minutes left) and another lady got out of her car to ask us if we were leaving. The lady who wanted to park sat behind us and waited, holding up a bus and a lot of other traffic! Another indication that this was not the most friendly place to be! So we gulped down our delicious cucumber quinoa salad and zucchini muffins and headed out - just as the parking meter hit "0 minutes." The lady found a different parking space, the meter maid came back and we were sort of glad to be leaving...

Statistics from College Board
Middle 50% of SAT scores:
Reading 690-800
Math 700-790
Writing 710-800
ACT 31-34

Percent of applicants admitted: 7%
Percent of Students who return for sophomore year: 98%


Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Cornell






Cornell has a beautiful campus in Ithaca, New York at the tip of one of the finger lakes. Ithaca is a lively town and has many sustainability initiatives going on. The famous Moosewood Restaurant is there as well as many, many other interesting and unusual restaurants. We ate at a place called Culture Shock where they had a lot of fermented foods like sauerkraut, Kombucha, and yogart integrated with their meals. The surrounding area has many waterfalls and hiking trails, and there is even a large waterfall right in the middle of campus. Just beyond the waterfall is an area called Cornell Plantation where there are acres and acres of different kinds of gardens. There are also many gardens throughout the campus which makes is a beautiful place for walking.

The best thing about our visit to the area was that we stayed at Ithaca's Ecovillage which is a well established shared living village in which people share the land and the running of the village. There is an organic farm on the 175 acre property that feeds the people who live there as a CSA (Community Supported Agriculture), and there is also a community garden. We stayed at a Bed and Breakfast there and were greeted with the opportunity to pick raspberries and fresh greens out of the owner's garden. Mollie and I went for a walk in the woods the last morning we were there and we picked handfuls and handfuls of wild black raspberries. We felt right at home and were ready to move in by the time it was time to leave!

The Cornell campus is large and about 20,000 students go to school there. It has been structured differently than the other Ivy League schools because it is funded partially as a state school and partially as a private college. There are 7 (I think) different undergraduate colleges under the umbrella of the university and a student has to apply and be accepted to one of the colleges rather than applying to Cornell as a whole unit. If a student wants to change their major they have to apply and be accepted into another college. The structure with the different colleges and the size of the campus made it a bit overwhelming and I think it could be difficult for an undergraduate student to have to be clear enough about their direction in life to know which college to apply to.

The different colleges sometimes have the same major, but with a different emphasis. For example, there is a biology major both in the liberal arts college and in one of the science college (I don't remember what the science college is called). The biology classes and professors are the same for both majors, but the requirements of the colleges are different. The liberal arts degree would be a well-rounded degree in which the student would take literature, art, math, etc., and the science oriented degree would have more science requirements. This gives students a lot of options, but I think it could also be difficult for undergrads to navigate and figure out which emphasis they want. I mean, how would you know all that as a 20 year old?

One of the programs I really, really liked was called the China, Asia, Pacific (CAPS) program. Its purpose is to train future leaders to know a lot about China and it includes an intensive study of Chinese, classes in economics and political science, and an internship in both Bejing and Washington D.C. That sounded like a great opportunity for Mollie and I'd like to learn more about it.

Statistics from College Board:
Middle 50% of SAT:
Reading 640-730
Math 670-770
ACT 29-33

Percentage of applicants accepted: 18%
Percentage of students who return for sophomore year: 96%